TL;DR
Animal Outlook’s recent undercover investigation at Cooke Aquaculture’s Maine hatchery found continued cruelty and welfare issues seven years after initial exposure. The company’s promises of reform appear unfulfilled, raising concerns about industry accountability.
A new undercover investigation by Animal Outlook has documented ongoing animal welfare violations at Cooke Aquaculture’s Maine hatchery, revealing systemic cruelty despite the company’s previous promises of reform following a 2019 exposé.
In 2019, Animal Outlook uncovered severe cruelty at Cooke’s hatchery, prompting the company to apologize and pledge reforms. However, a follow-up investigation in late 2025 has found similar conditions, with workers repeatedly beating fish, leaving them to suffocate, and causing other forms of inhumane treatment. The investigation documented 133 instances of improper handling, along with fungal infections, deformities, and unexplained mass mortalities. Cooke Aquaculture has not responded directly to the latest findings but stated it is reviewing the footage and will take disciplinary action where appropriate. The company remains certified by Best Aquaculture Practices, which claims to promote responsible farming, but critics argue that industry-wide cruelty persists despite such certifications.
Why It Matters
This development underscores the limited impact of investigations and industry promises in improving animal welfare at factory farms and hatcheries. It raises questions about the effectiveness of voluntary certifications and highlights the ongoing cycle of abuse that consumers cannot reliably trust when companies pledge reform. The findings contribute to broader concerns about oversight and accountability in the livestock and seafood industries, emphasizing the need for stronger regulation.
fish welfare monitoring equipment
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Background
In 2019, Animal Outlook’s undercover video revealed egregious cruelty at Cooke’s Maine hatchery, leading to a public apology and promises of reform. Despite these assurances, subsequent investigations have repeatedly documented similar conditions, suggesting that promises made after initial exposés often go unfulfilled. This pattern is common across the industry, where investigations have exposed widespread inhumane practices, yet meaningful change remains elusive without stricter oversight or legal enforcement.
“We know that crowding animals in these tanks leads to welfare problems, and treating animals as commodities inherently results in cruelty.”
— Ben Williamson, Animal Outlook
“It looks to me like they have a systemic welfare issue at this farm.”
— Culum Brown, Macquarie University
“Cooke USA takes animal welfare very seriously. Appropriate disciplinary measures will be taken with respect to employees who have not followed company policy.”
— Cooke Aquaculture spokesperson
aquaculture fish handling tools
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What Remains Unclear
It remains unclear whether Cooke Aquaculture will implement meaningful reforms following the latest investigation or if the company’s certification by Best Aquaculture Practices will be revoked or strengthened. The company has not responded directly to detailed questions about the specific violations documented.
fish health and fungal infection treatment
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What’s Next
Further investigations by watchdog groups and regulatory agencies are likely, potentially leading to legal action or stricter oversight. Industry critics will continue to push for mandatory regulations to prevent such abuses, and consumers may question the reliability of voluntary certifications.
fish deformity treatment products
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
Will Cooke Aquaculture face legal consequences for these violations?
As of now, there are no known legal charges against Cooke related to the recent findings. Regulatory agencies have not announced any enforcement actions but may investigate further.
Are certifications like Best Aquaculture Practices sufficient to ensure animal welfare?
Critics argue that such voluntary certifications are inadequate without strict enforcement or legal standards, as they can be issued despite ongoing violations.
What impact could this investigation have on consumer trust?
The findings may lead consumers to question the reliability of industry promises and certifications, potentially affecting purchasing decisions and industry reputation.
What reforms are necessary to prevent such cruelty in the future?
Stronger government oversight, mandatory regulations, and transparent reporting are needed to ensure animal welfare standards are genuinely enforced across the industry.
Source: Vox
